I started a thread on BigBlueInteractive to nickname The Tyree Catch. Here's what we/they've come up with so far. I've bolded the ones I like the best:
The Hel-Mitt Catch
The Hat Trick
The Great Escape
No name, just a signal. Place both hands about a foot over the top of your head with criss crossed fingers
The Holy MutherF'ing Sh** Catch
The Slip, Whip and Grip
The Crowning Moment
The "Kiss from God"
If Tomlinson is LT to ESPN Then this is "The Catch"
The Helmet Catch
The Helmet Grab
The Great Escape... then the Great Capture
The PERFECT catch
I AM LEGEND
The Scrambling Houdini
Update: Sports Guy is calling it "the Miracle Play to Be Named Later"